Immigration Fraud

Immigration Fraud: When A Waiver Can Help And When It Cannot

Immigration waivers are amazing tools that help someone in a truly desperate situation. But you need to know when and how to use them, and when they can and cannot help in order to be successful. Here, we will examine the most recent Federal cases about Immigration waivers and why the applicants could not use them despite their best efforts.

Recent Federal Cases on Immigration Fraud Waivers and Understanding I-601 Waiver Qualifications

Immigration fraud, particularly involving misrepresentation, poses significant challenges for individuals seeking lawful status in the United States. The I-601 waiver offers a potential remedy for those deemed inadmissible due to such infractions. Recent federal cases provide insight into the application and limitations of these waivers.

Recent Federal Cases

Reese v. Garland (5th Cir. 2023)

In this case, Leaphiny Reese and Thou Samphear were convicted of visa fraud and faced removal based on that conviction. They sought relief through a fraud waiver under Section 237(a)(1)(H) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA). The Fifth Circuit Court held that this waiver could not overcome their grounds for removal based on criminal conviction, emphasizing that certain waivers have specific applicability and may not cover all grounds of inadmissibility.

Bador v. Garland (2d Cir. 2024)

Shlomo Bador, an Israeli citizen, obtained conditional permanent resident status through marriage. After suspicions of marriage fraud arose, his conditional status was terminated due to failure to file a joint petition to remove conditions. Bador sought a fraud waiver under Section 237(a)(1)(H) of the INA. The Second Circuit Court concluded that this waiver does not apply to removability under Section 237(a)(1)(D)(i), which pertains to the termination of conditional permanent residence for reasons independent of fraud.

Understanding I-601 Waiver Qualifications

The I-601 waiver, or "Application for Waiver of Grounds of Inadmissibility," allows certain individuals who are inadmissible to the U.S. to apply for a waiver of specific grounds of inadmissibility, including fraud or willful misrepresentation under INA Section 212(a)(6)(C)(i).

Eligibility Criteria:

• Qualifying Relative: The applicant must have a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident spouse or parent. Notably, children are not considered qualifying relatives for this waiver.
• Extreme Hardship: The applicant must demonstrate that refusal of admission would result in extreme hardship to the qualifying relative. This hardship must go beyond the typical consequences of family separation and may include factors like medical conditions, financial difficulties, or country conditions in the applicant's home country.

Application Process:

• Form I-601 Submission: Complete and submit Form I-601, providing detailed evidence of the qualifying relative's extreme hardship.
• Supporting Documentation: Include medical records, financial statements, affidavits, and any other relevant evidence to substantiate claims of hardship.
• Legal Assistance: Given the complexities involved, consulting with an experienced immigration attorney is advisable to ensure a thorough and compelling application.

Limitations:

• Discretionary Nature: Approval of the I-601 waiver is discretionary. Even if eligibility criteria are met, the adjudicating officer assesses the totality of circumstances to determine if a favorable exercise of discretion is warranted.
• Scope of Waiver: The waiver applies only to the specific grounds of inadmissibility indicated in the application. Other grounds may require separate waivers or may not be waivable.

The I-601 Waiver provides relief for certain grounds of inadmissibility, such as unlawful presence, fraud, or willful misrepresentation, and certain criminal grounds. However, not all immigration violations can be waived using the I-601. Below is a list of common immigration violations that cannot be waived with the I-601 Waiver:

1. Security-Related Grounds:
   • Terrorism-Related Grounds: Involvement in or support of terrorism under INA § 212(a)(3)(B).
   • Espionage or Sabotage: Acts that compromise national security under INA § 212(a)(3)(A).
   • Membership in Totalitarian Organizations: Current or former membership in certain organizations under INA § 212(a)(3)(D).
   • Threat to National Security: Persons determined to pose a danger to U.S. security under INA § 212(a)(3)(C).
2. Human Rights Violations:
   • Genocide: Participation in genocide under INA § 212(a)(3)(E)(ii).
   • Torture or Extrajudicial Killing: Individuals who engaged in acts of torture or extrajudicial killings under INA § 212(a)(3)(E)(iii).
   • Nazi Persecution: Persecution of others during the Nazi era under INA § 212(a)(3)(E)(i).
3. Certain Criminal Grounds:
   • Drug Trafficking: Convictions for drug trafficking under INA § 212(a)(2)(C).
   • Drug Addiction or Abuse: Current drug addiction or abuse under INA § 212(a)(1)(A)(iv).
   • Serious Criminal Offenses: Such as aggravated felonies without rehabilitation or long enough time outside the U.S.
4. Prior Deportation and Illegal Reentry:
   • Permanent Bar (INA § 212(a)(9)(C)): Individuals who re-entered the U.S. unlawfully after a prior removal or accumulated over one year of unlawful presence and re-entered unlawfully. They are barred for at least 10 years and cannot waive the inadmissibility through an I-601 waiver.
5. Misrepresentation in Citizenship Claims:
   • False Claim to U.S. Citizenship: Making a false claim to U.S. citizenship under INA § 212(a)(6)(C)(ii) is generally not waivable, except in very limited circumstances involving minors or those unaware of the misrepresentation.
6. Public Charge:
   • Inadmissibility Based on Public Charge (INA § 212(a)(4)): This ground is not waivable using the I-601 waiver. Instead, applicants may need to overcome it by demonstrating sufficient financial resources or securing a qualifying sponsor.
7. Lack of Required Vaccinations:
   • Failure to Meet Vaccination Requirements: This ground of inadmissibility under INA § 212(a)(1)(A)(ii) typically requires compliance rather than a waiver.
8. Health-Related Grounds:
   • Communicable Diseases: Certain communicable diseases like tuberculosis may render a person inadmissible unless cured or mitigated. These are not typically addressed by the I-601 waiver.

Additional Notes

• Multiple Grounds of Inadmissibility: If a person is inadmissible under multiple grounds, they may need separate waivers or other forms of relief.
• Specific Waivers for Refugees and Asylees: Certain grounds that cannot be waived with an I-601 might still be addressed through other waivers specific to refugees or asylees.

Understanding whether your specific grounds of inadmissibility can be waived is essential. Always consult with an experienced immigration attorney for guidance on your unique situation

Conclusion

Navigating the complexities of immigration fraud waivers requires a thorough understanding of both legal standards and recent judicial interpretations. The I-601 waiver provides a pathway for overcoming certain inadmissibility issues, but its success largely depends on demonstrating substantial hardship to qualifying relatives and meeting all legal requirements. Staying informed about recent case law and seeking professional legal guidance are crucial steps for individuals facing these challenges.

• Immigration Reform
• Country Conditions
• Hardship Waiver
• Business Visa
• Immigration Forms
• Family Visa
• Work Visas
• Provisional Waivers
• Green Card
• Visas
• Deportation
• Asylum
• Citizenship
• Immigration
• Discrimination
• Litigation
• Criminal Law